The creation of synthetic human embryos raises ethical concerns

Reports indicate that scientists have successfully generated synthetic human embryos without the use of eggs or sperm. This development has sparked profound ethical inquiries. The artificially created embryos, which are in their early stages of development, offer potential insights into the study of human embryonic development and may provide explanations for pregnancy loss.

While there are no current proposals to grow these synthetic embryos into babies, the rapid advancement in this field has surpassed the ongoing discussions regarding their ethical and legal implications.

To prevent a potential negative impact on public perception, Professor James Briscoe from the Francis Crick Institute emphasizes the need for the field to proceed cautiously, with careful and transparent considerations.

The unveiling of human synthetic embryos took place during the annual gathering of the International Society for Stem Cell Research.

Synthetic embryos, alternatively referred to as “embryo models,” bear a resemblance to embryos and are utilized for research purposes, although they are not exact replicas.

The research is conducted by Prof Magdalena Zernicka-Goetz, who operates laboratories at both the University of Cambridge and the California Institute of Technology.

As the complete details have not been published or made accessible for scientific scrutiny, many researchers are hesitant to comment on the significance of the reports at this time.

The fundamental principle behind synthetic embryos is that they are created from a stem cell rather than through the fusion of an egg and sperm.

Stem cells possess the remarkable ability to differentiate into any cell type within the body. With the right coaxing, they can be directed to form embryos, even developing into a beating heart.

For the first time, researchers have successfully accomplished this using human material. However, it is worth noting that these embryos are not technically “synthetic” since they originate from cells cultured in a laboratory setting, derived from a traditional embryo.

Prof Zernicka-Goetz, in an interview with The Guardian newspaper, described the achievement as “beautiful” and emphasized that the synthetic embryo was entirely formed using embryonic stem cells.

Prof Zernicka-Goetz has already made significant progress in developing synthetic mouse embryos, which show signs of a developing brain and a beating heart.

In China, scientists conducted an experiment involving the implantation of synthetic monkey embryos into female monkeys. However, all of the pregnancies resulting from this procedure ended in failure.

Synthetic embryos exhibit variations in behavior compared to natural embryos, raising questions about the appropriate regulatory framework for their use in research. The governance surrounding their research application remains uncertain.

Professor Briscoe commented, stating, “On one hand, stem cell-based models of human embryos could present an ethical and more accessible alternative to the use of in-vitro fertilization (IVF)-derived human embryos.”

Professor Briscoe emphasized that as stem cell-derived models of human embryos become more comparable to real human embryos, there is a heightened necessity for clear regulations and guidelines governing their utilization.

The majority of countries adhere to the 14-day rule in human embryo research, which permits the growth of an embryo resulting from the fertilization of a human egg for a maximum of 14 days.

However, these “embryo models” do not fall under the legal definition of “embryos” and are not subject to the same regulatory laws.

Dr. Ildem Akerman of the University of Birmingham acknowledged that the findings suggest the potential to extend the growth of these cells beyond the existing 14-day limit, leading to additional understanding of human development. However, it is crucial to recognize that the mere ability to do something does not automatically validate its pursuit.




Source :

By Ryan

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *